Title: Black Boots and Buttonhooks
Author: Phyllis Johnston
Series: The May series, book 2
Major Themes: New Zealand, Pioneers, Farm Life
Synopsis: When May’s father and brothers had a hut built on their new farm, May and her mother moved to the remote location to be with them.
Six or eight years ago, I read Black Boots and Buttonhooks to my children, after spotting it on a friend’s bookshelf. We had already read the first May book a few years earlier. Last year, I had the opportunity to buy the first three books in the series, and a few minutes later, I found the fifth book just after a friend of mine bought the fourth one, so I decided we would read the entire series aloud.
Publisher’s description:
In this sequel to No One Went to Town, the Tarrants are clearing land near Piopio in the King Country, New Zealand. At first, the conditions are too tough for May and her mother, who spend the winter in Te Kuiti, then a land rush town. Staying at the Grand Hotel is exciting, and May sees her first moving picture and is invited to a Maori wedding.
In the spring, she travels to Piopio and out to the Paemako farm by coach and sledge. Now that she is nine, May is old enough to turn the grindstone, milk the cows, and ride a horse—and old enough to get caned for disobeying the teacher at her bush school. She becomes a proper King Country girl.
Black Boots and Buttonhooks is a true story, based on the recollections of the author’s family.
My thoughts:
We really enjoyed this glimpse into pioneer life in 1907. It’s hard to believe how rough life was at that point in the middle of the North Island! The story about how May and her mother rode on the coach from Te Kuiti to Paemako is incredible. After reading that, I found myself looking at the roads around us in a different way. We can’t even imagine traveling without some sort of formed road.
I was interested to notice the (lack of) religious life in the Tarrant family. While she and her mother lived in Te Kuiti, May went to Sunday School, but that seemed to consist merely of learning the catechism. I didn’t notice any other references to church or Bible reading. Her mother was very concerned about appearances and making sure things were done properly, like at “Home” (England), but there was no mention of doing what pleased God. They had good morals, but a couple of times May disobeyed her parents and concealed it without being found out.
Overall, I like Black Boots and Buttonhooks, as history. It is the story of a family and how they experienced the settling of a large farming area of New Zealand. It is a book that should have some parental input, however, with discussion about a few chapters.
WARNING: Chapter 2: By Jove. Chapter 3: Talk of a woman who got lost and died. Chapter 4: Drunk men fighting, a young woman died. Chapter 5: Gosh. Chapter 7: Teasing about boyfriends/girlfriends, boy and girl fighting, gosh. Chapter 8: Boy choked girl. Chapter 9: Girl lied. Chapter 10: Golly twice, gosh, girl got whipped. Chapter 11: Gosh, boy drowned. Chapter 12: The dickens of a time, gosh. In a couple of chapters, May concealed things from her parents so she wouldn’t get in trouble, and was not found out.
Age levels:
Listening Level—Ages 8 – 12, Family Friendly
Reading Independently—Ages 12 – 15
Links to buy this book:
AbeBooks: View Choices on AbeBooks.com




